The Environment & Sustainable Development

Comparison of Different Energy Sources

Non-renewable   Renewable

 

Coal

Gas

Nuclear

 

Solar

Wind

Hydro-electric

Geothermal

Efficiency

2 - 3 kWh/kg

4 - 5 kWh/kg

45 - 50 000 kWh/kg

 

comparative figures not available

comparative figures not available

comparative figures not available

comparative figures not available

Cost (US cents/kWh)

OECD 1998 (exc.Japan)

2.5 – 4.5

2.3 – 4.7

2.5 – 4.1

 

12-20

5

comparative figures not available

comparative figures not available

Cost effective

yes

yes

yes

 

comparative figures not available

intermittent, cannot meet base load

yes

in a few localities

Ability to meet base load demand

yes

yes

yes

 

no

no

yes

no

Source reliability and availability

good

good

good

 

variable daily & weather dependent

variable & weather dependent

seasonal dependence

not many suitable sites

Back-up power

not needed

not needed

not needed

 

needed

needed

needed

needed

Export dollars for Australia
(end of 2000)

$8.7 billion

$1.9 billion

$.367 billion

 

some from sale of technology

some from sale of technology

some from sale of technology

unknown

Greenhouse gas emission

1kg of CO2/kWh

0.5kg of CO2/kWh

none

 

none

none

none

none

Emissions to environment

NOx, SO2

NOx, SO2

steam

 

nil

nil

nil

nil

Other wastes

ash, flyash

4 milligrams of radioactive spent fuel/kWh

 

toxic waste from production of solar panels

nil

nil

nil

Other environmental impacts

extensive mining, major transportation,
acid rain

production facilities, pipelines,
acid rain

limited mining and associated tailings storage facilities

 

on roofs

can be unsightly, noisy, birds fly into rotors

changes in ecosystems through dams flooding large areas

 

top


The Uranium SA Website is supported by the South Australian Chamber of Mines and Energy
© 2001 SA Chamber of Mines and Energy.
Information, artwork, text, data and pictures on this web site may be reproduced freely with due acknowledgment of SA Chamber of Mines and Energy.
It would be appreciated if you could please let us know what material you are using.
All feedback is most welcome. Please contact:
uraniumsa@resourcessa.org.au www.uraniumsa.org